Why Heat Pumps Go Wrong

The heat pump industry has a trust problem. Here’s what goes wrong.

Eco-scheme scandals. Confusing quotes. Jargon-heavy surveys with widely varying results. No wonder so many homeowners who want to do the right thing end up doing nothing at all. Here’s some of what can go wrong, and why it matters more than most people realise.

The problem with standard heat loss calculations

Most heat pump installers use software tools that calculate heat loss from a visual survey of your home — they look at your wall types, window sizes, floor area, and roof, then apply standard U-values (measures of how much heat each element loses) from lookup tables. It’s a reasonable starting point, but it treats your home as if it were an identical copy of every other home of the same age and construction type. It isn’t.

Real buildings are full of variation. The actual thermal performance of a wall, floor or roof depends on workmanship, alterations over the decades, local materials, and dozens of other factors that no surveyor can see. The result is a calculated heat loss figure that may be very different to what your home actually loses.

Build Test Solutions research

BTS research showed the average difference between calculated and measured heat loss = 35%. 59% of homes have their heat loss overestimated. In some cases, measured heat loss is less than half the calculated figure.

Source: Build Test Solutions

The error cuts both ways – depending on your home

The direction of the error tends to follow a consistent pattern depending on the age of your property.

Older homes: heat loss is usually overestimated

Pre-1965 properties — Victorian, Edwardian, and interwar terraces and semis — are consistently shown to perform better than standard calculations predict. Solid walls, while uninsulated by modern standards, often perform better than assumed. Party walls adjoining heated neighbouring properties lose far less heat than assumed in many surveys. And decades of minor improvements — draught-proofing, secondary glazing, added loft insulation — are rarely fully captured in a desktop survey which doesn’t also consider actual data from the current heating system.

The result: an oversized heat pump, a higher upfront cost, and a system that in many cases will suffer from frequent cycling — turning on and off more frequently than it should — reducing efficiency and increasing wear.

New builds: heat loss is often underestimated

Newly built homes carry the opposite risk. Design specifications look excellent on paper, but the gap between as-designed and as-built performance is well documented. Poor workmanship, gaps in insulation, and air leakage not captured in the design model mean actual heat loss can be significantly higher than predicted. An undersized heat pump in a new build risks falling short on the coldest days — leading homeowners to rely on backup electric resistance heating, which is far less efficient.

“An oversized heat pump incurs higher capital costs — around 10% on average — alongside higher maintenance costs and lower running efficiency.”

Build Test Solutions Accurate Heat Loss Measurement is Vital to Heat Pump Sizing

Build Test Solutions, alongside Veritherm and Elmhurst Energy, have called for industry standards and software tools to be updated to recognise measured heat loss — not just modelled estimates — as part of the heat pump design process. Until that becomes the norm, the best protection for a homeowner is a survey which also looks at actual data on how the home heats and cools.

A better approach: heat loss from real data

The strange thing about most heat loss surveys today is that they ignore an obvious fact. If you want to know how much heat a home loses on a cold day, an obvious starting point is to ask how much heat the home actually lost on recent cold days. If you have data on the internal temperature, external temperature and heat output from a gas or oil boiler, then you can estimate actual heat loss. Nowadays, Smart meters and Smart Thermostats mean that a lot of data is available if you know how to get hold of it.

My free calculator estimates your home’s heat loss from your actual energy consumption — your smart meter readings or gas bills — rather than solely relying on a visual survey and lookup tables. This approach considers actual data on true thermal performance of your specific home, not just a statistical average of homes like yours. It gives you a way to sense-check the size of heat pump you’re quoted.

  • Taking account of your actual energy data, not just assumed u-values
  • Accounts for party walls, alterations and real-world performance
  • Result: a heat pump size matched to your home’s genuine heat demand

Every home is unique. Make sure your survey treats it that way.

Find out what size heat pump your home actually needs

Check your home with the free calculator, then get a survey from an installer I trust.